The Costco Method: Building Trust through Transparency 

Readers of the blog know that Costco is my favorite store. It’s a brand that I trust. And the reason I trust the company is simple. Transparency. 

Costco caps their mark-up at 14% on outside brands and a whopping 15% for their in-house Kirkland Signature brand. 

Now, keep in mind, this doesn’t mean Costco is cheap. I can’t escape the place without dropping at least $300, but part of the reason I spend so freely while walking the warehouse is the knowledge that they aren’t taking me for a ride. 

I also trust them to do my bidding. I trust that with over $140 billion in annual sales, they can negotiate some decent pricing from their suppliers. Better than I could do on my own. 

So yeah, I have no reason to take my peanut butter addiction to any other outfits. But also… 

Hot dogs. 

Costco gains trust through transparency


It seems clear that Costco’s success has less to do with selling me a 6-pound can of queso, and more to do with a transparent business model that jives with my buying habits. 

Costco gains trust through transparency
A 10 year old WinWithFlynn would jump right in this bucket of cheese product

Pricing, in most scenarios, is not a secret. Any public company you come across has published their margins for the world to see. 

And yet.  

And yet, salespeople and buyers get all awkward when it comes up. 

Our mind goes to the carnival barking salesperson at the local used car lot. The guy who needs to run everything pricing related “past her manager,” which kicks off an unbearable cat and mouse negotiation for that used GMC Jimmy.  

The used car lot could do much better by just using the Costco Method. Replace that huckster. Hire someone in a red vest to answer questions and help customers find what they need, post the transparent pricing, and make a few billion. 

Blogger turned bestselling author turned podcaster Tim Ferriss sold this way when he was a new graduate.  

“I would open my pitch book and walk them through the industry. Here are the providers, here is what they do, here is how they do it, here is what I do. I am the same as everyone else, except with me, you get honesty and transparency and great customer support. So, I became this company’s number-one salesperson. I broke all their sales records following this really simple formula of just selling honesty and transparency in a broken industry.”

-Timothy Ferriss, Tools of Titans 

I don’t know if your industry is broken, but many of them are. The first clue in finding out might be the level of transparency the company, or industry uses. 

Shall we look at banking?  

When I look at my Bank of America savings account, I can’t find the interest rate. 

But when I go to my credit union account, it is one click away. The credit union didn’t need to give up any trade secrets to earn my trust, no intellectual property was exchanged. They just shared the basics.  

When you feel that customers are getting value, when you don’t have anything to hide, those details are nbd (no big deal). 

The rates? 

  • B of A: .03% 
  • BECU: 2.75% 

Are you still wondering why Bank of America doesn’t make this information easy to find?  

People and companies don’t like sharing unflattering information. And as it turns out, many of them would rather put on some concealer than wash their face. 

Even the real estate business, which is an absolute racket, is somewhat transparent. You know the last purchase price. You know the neighborhood comps. And you know the agent is taking 3 percent off the top.

Circling back to Tim. His willingness to be transparent signals to his customers that he has nothing to hide. It signals that he is not trying to extract from them. 

Same with Costco. 

You might be thinking, “cool, that works for software sales, and real estate, and trail mix, but my company is like, really complex.” 

Whatever helps you sleep at night. 

I’m guessing Warren Buffett has bought and sold more companies than you, closed more deals than you, and guess what? He is maybe the most transparent of them all. 

He published the letter he sends to companies when assessing their interest in selling. Here are a few pull quotes, I’ll even break it out in the AIDA format for you. (If you don’t know about AIDA, please read this excellent book). 

Attention: 

“Berkshire is another kind of buyer — a rather unusual one. We buy to keep, but we don’t have, and don’t expect to have, operating people in our parent organization. All of the businesses we own are run autonomously to an extraordinary degree.” 

Interest: 

“You would know exactly with whom you are dealing. You would not have one executive negotiate the deal only to have someone else in charge a few years later, or have the president regretfully tell you that his board of directors required this change or that.” 

Desire: 

“It’s only fair to tell you that you would be no richer after the sale than now. The ownership of your business already makes you wealthy and soundly invested. A sale would change the form of your wealth, but it wouldn’t change its amount. There is often a sound reason to sell but, if the transaction is a fair one, the reason is not so that the seller can become wealthier.” 

Action: 

“I will not pester you; if you have any possible interest in selling, I would appreciate your call. I would be extraordinarily proud to have Berkshire, along with the key members of your family, own ____________; I believe we would do very well financially; and I believe you would have just as much fun running the business over the next 20 years as you have had during the past 20.” 

If that’s not transparent, I don’t know what is. And it’s been good enough to close deals with all types of businesses, from NetJets to Dairy Queen. 

Transparency tips the scales. 

Because, let’s face it, in a lot of exchanges, the products are not differentiated.  

Robert Smith, the billionaire founder of Vista Equity Partners, said “Software companies taste like chicken. They’re selling different products, but 80% of what they do is pretty much the same.”  

And it’s not just the software business. 

When the product is not differentiated, you, the seller, need to be.  

In a lot of ways, the seller is a middleman. A middleman will always be looked at with a bit of skepticism because both sides, supplier, and buyer, would rather keep your cut for themselves.  

The only way to overcome that feeling is to create value inside your process. 

For Costco, that’s negotiating deals on your behalf, transparent pricing, and hot dogs. 

For Tim Ferris that’s being an open book, a resource for them in the industry. What many consulting firms call a “trusted advisor.”

And for Warren, it’s being so open and honest that the pitch can be published inside Berkshire Hathaway’s Annual report. 

We are operating in the age of transparency. You can run and hide if you’d like, but that act will speak louder than any words you can say. You are better off opening up. 

“Honesty, directness, and transparency,” Daniel Pink writes, “has become the better, more pragmatic, long-term route.” 


If you enjoyed this, share it with a friend.

Get the next one by email. New essays, plus email-only extras, downloads, and audio.

Enjoying the Flynnternet? You can support the writing.

Similar Posts