Luck and Skill and Stories
At one point in my life, while working for Wells Fargo Financial, while living in a rented basement in Tacoma, while being force fed Dido “White Flag” 12 times a day, I decided I’d become a golf pro.
Not a professional golfer. A golf professional. The guy working at the local golf course giving instructions.
I’ve never been a great golfer, but I figured, “those who can’t, teach.” So, I made my way to the driving range after work, hammered on a bucket, and finally got up the nerve to talk with the pro on staff.
It turns out, becoming a golf professional was going to be just a bit harder than I anticipated.
The criteria?
In addition to adhering to the PGA constitution and understanding all the rules, you’d need to show some proficiency with, you know, the actual game of golf.
Playing Ability Test (PAT): One day, 36 holes, 15 over par or better.
I was a little closer to 10 over after 9, but perhaps with some practice, and a lot of lessons from this guy, I could whittle away at my handicap.
But that wasn’t it.
Once you pass the PAT, you enter the “Swing Anatomy and Mechanics” portion of your certification. Hitting it straight, rolling it in, that’s all well and good but you need to know why you hit it straight and roll it in. And more to the point, for those future clients, you need to know why they couldn’t.
You need to be able to make all the shots.
Yes, even the terrible ones.
Can you step up to the tee box and hit a duck hook like Phil the oncologist who plays every Wednesday afternoon? Can you send a banana ball slicing into the other fairway like little Timmy did in the club championship?
You’d better learn.
Because a certified golf professional needs to have the skill and ability to swing it like their clients, so they can then fix those swings, and give hope to yet another generation of golfers.
They say that “golf is a good walk spoiled,” but with proper care and feeding from your local golf professional, you’ll hit just enough good ones to keep you crawling back for more.
The trick is knowing which ones you can take credit for.
I Meant to do That
Pee-wee Herman said it after every slip up or screw up.
“I meant to do that.”
Was it sarcasm? I’m not sure, I was too young, but I can tell you this much. Every kid in America followed suit. Shoot and airball, crash your bike, trip in front of your girl.
“I meant to do that.”
Of course, Pee Wee didn’t actually mean to do it and neither did we. It was a joke, a cover, we were trying to brush it off and move forward.
But what if you actually meant to do that?
What if you could fail on purpose? It’s harder than you might think.
Every winter, when the drizzle takes over the pacific northwest, something comes over me. A wave of emotion. I’ll catch the tail end of a random basketball game on TNT and get tossed into a fit of nostalgia, rage, depression, and self-loathing that I assume will only be rectified when my Seattle Supersonics return to prominence.
Years ago, in one of these spirals, I found the tail end of a Spurs game. They were playing the Blazers. This was in the post Tim Duncan years.
Spurs were down three with time running out. So what do the Blazers do? They foul Manu Ginóbili. This is a common strategy. I mean, you’d rather foul Tony Parker but it’s not a perfect world. The idea is to send Manu to the line for two shots, so he can’t hit the three and tie the game.
To counter the strategy, the Spurs and Manu will sink just the first shot, and then intentionally miss the second. After the miss, the Spurs will snap up the rebound and knock down a two for the tie or a three for the win.
At least, that’s how Coach Popovich drew it up.
Except Manu, as skilled as he is, misses the first shot.
Well crap, I guess that happens. Even the best free throw shooters miss from time to time.
No problem. Manu just needs to miss the second. This time his teammate can’t settle for the two, they’ll need to quickly rebound and kick it out for a three pointer. Push the game to overtime.
Except, apparently, that’s kinda hard too.
Manu accidentally makes the damn thing. Blazers get the ball, inbound it, and take the victory.
What the hell man, I thought this guy had some skill?
The Skill-Luck Spectrum
If Manu can’t knock down free throws on demand, and more to the point, if he can’t even miss on demand, what is really skill? And what is luck?
Turns out those are two sides of the same coin. Or two sides of a spectrum, as Michael Mauboussin has explored.
Some things are pure luck. Flipping a coin, or rolling dice, for example.
Some things are pure skill. Chess, even checkers, or solving some advance math equation.

If the more advanced, the more knowledgeable, the more skilled player wins 99.9% of the time, that is a game of skill. And as much as I’d like to keep harping on Manu, I know that his Spurs teams would beat down my son’s 5th grade squad 1,000 out of 1,000 times. So rest assured, basketball is still a game of skill.
One defining characteristic in games of skill: you can intentionally lose. “If I suggested that you should play slots, roulette, baccarat, or lottery and seek to lose,” Annie Duke said, “you could no more make yourself lose than you could make yourself win, as long as you continued playing.”
Ask yourself, can I lose on purpose? If you can, it’s skill. If not, it’s luck.
Try to lose a coin flip and you can’t. You might lose, but you can’t try to. You’ve got heads and tails. And try as you might to pick the wrong one, you’ll accidently get it right about 50 percent of the time.
But let’s progress beyond pure games of chance. Games that you can lose on purpose. Most of the time.
Texas Hold’em with the fellas? Poker has odds and psychology and strategy, and even so, you shove with a 10-2, you’ve got that shit eating grin on your face because you know you just lost and you’ll finally be able to grab a beer and take a pee.
But that little smirk throws everyone off. You almost look confident. What’s this guy thinking? Everyone folds. Congrats, you won on accident. And you pulled it off because, as much skill is involved in poker, it still has a healthy dose of luck.
And this is what makes the golf professional so impressive. Making all the shots is no easy feat, but even golf, a game of skill and strategy and mental toughness involves some luck. Last time I played I hit my best drive of the decade. After a few months of dry summer days, that sucker just rolled and rolled and rolled some more. Rolled too far I guess, because it eventually ended up crossing the cart path, knocking against a section that was bulging and breaking, root heave, changing the course of my Kirkland Signature (yellow) and finding a nice spot to nestle under a beautiful maple.
I joked that “I need to lay off the kettlebells.” Too much strength!
In other words, “I meant to do that.”
Extrapolate all the way out. The music business, the NBA, sports betting, and somewhere on that spectrum between pure skill and pure luck, is the endeavor of your choosing.
But it can all be so very confusing.
That tendency to explain things, to find reasons why something happened or didn’t? That might be a bigger issue than our inability to judge the odds surrounding us.
Maybe You Should Talk to Somebody
What happens when we get lucky?
We come up with reasons why it happened. The problem is that we come up with reasons besides luck.
We invent skills. We contrive knowledge.
Neuroscientist Michael Gazzaniga called it the “interpreter.” I think of it as the narrator. It sees things and wants to come up with a reason. Almost any reason will do.
Roll doubles a few times in a row, and you’ll tell yourself its because you shook your hand “just so.”
A few years ago, a group of friends started playing an annual poker game. Just like the one I described above. I’m not a great player. I know most of the rules. But I’m also the guy that can’t remember if a flush beats a full house.
Poker might be the greatest game, not because it’s all skill or all luck, but because it more closely mirrors our everyday interactions. Reading people. A little bit of bull shit. Odds, statistics, strategy, gamesmanship, honor, class, all of it.
And it also sits pretty square in the middle of that luck and skill spectrum. See, there I go again. It is clearly on the luck side of the ledger.
The first two times we played, I was the last man standing. Pretty lucky, I’d say, but you know what started to happen? Deep down, no matter how much I knew it was luck, I started thinking that maybe, just maybe, I had a knack for the game.
Some innate ability.
The guys have made sure to squash that thought, not even sniffing the purse our last few times together.
We create a story for why it happened. Really good stories get cemented as superstition. And a certain part of the population is more superstitious that others.
“Knock on wood.”
“That’s bad juju!”
This is what I was doing with my poker winnings. Instead of counting my lucky stars, I thought I was a star.
Good outcomes, repeated, invite reasons.
Bad outcome? Those get excuses.
But they are one and the same.
The narrator has never heard of luck. Too busy talking to hear a damn thing.
We like getting lucky, but we don’t really embrace the idea of being lucky. We want what we get, what we do, all the good stuff at least, to be skill. And we want the bad stuff, the shit, to be a bad break. Luck.
The narrator is more than happy to write that script. To make shit up.
We fictionalize. We turn dots and data points into lines and trends and reasons.
And stories.
We see an outcome and we paint a mental picture about how it came to be. The reasons.
Part of this is self-preservation. All the inmates at Shawshank are innocent, right? “Lawyer fucked me.” But can it help? Fooling yourself like this?
I’ve wondered if embracing bad luck can somehow make us luckier, by keeping us in the game.
John McEnroe would endlessly argue points that went against him rather than own his mistakes.
After Deontay Wilder lost his heavyweight bout against Tyson Fury, he said the ring-walk costume was too heavy. (It was insanely heavy. And just insane.)

Psychologically it’s called a self-serving bias: successes get credited to skill and character; failures get parked on the lie, the wind, the ref, the market, the staff, the timing. We slide them towards luck.
The excuse-making vs. credit-taking split is larger among individual athletes than team athletes—when you lose alone, there are no teammates to share the blame with, so we look to share it with anyone or anything we can.
The Narrator starts with the result and works backward, finding a reason why it is and why it could never be otherwise.
The Engineer begins with the mechanism. Testing it. Trying to break it. Like that golf professional executing a perfect duck hook on command.
Could you do it again?
Could you make it fail?
Could you reproduce the result without the lucky break?
Daniel Kahneman said, “The proof that you truly understand a pattern of behavior is that you know how to reverse it.”
When it comes to skill and luck, keep Kahneman in mind. The most important thing is the ability to reverse the pattern, not explain it away.
And as Manu found out, reversing things, failing on purpose, can be more difficult than anticipated.
Flips & Flight
Let’s host a coin flipping tournament, shall we?
We’ll gather 100,000 people, line them up in pairs across a table 20 miles long, and flip. After round one we have fifty thousand winners, fifty thousand losers. That should come as no surprise to most of you, math is all the way towards the skill side of our spectrum.
After round two, the field halves again. 25,000 have now won twice in a row.
By round five, we’re down to about 3,125 people and with those five victories we see these winners strutting to their next matchup.
En route, a few will pause to explain to the losers still in attendance that they’ve “always had a knack for coin flipping.”
Keep halving.
By round nine, a few hundred remain, and reporters want a moment of their time. To know their secrets.
We get quotes about deliberate practice and gut feelings and instincts.
Eventually a dozen people have won fifteen straight flips. Experts no doubt. I can see the headlines now: Greatest Coin Flippers in History. Biographies. Advice columns. Fortunes.
These are the stories we tell. This is the narrator in action.
A streak becomes skill, and we push any evidence of luck under our bed.
But there are occupations and industries that are less luck based. Why not take on those?
Well, let’s start with this: they’re hard.
The Wright Brothers set up camp on the dunes of Kitty Hawk, testing gliders and prototypes. Back home in Ohio, they built their own wind tunnel to dial in their designs.
They crashed. They tested. They adjusted.
And then they crashed again.
Through hundreds of low-altitude tests they were improving this machine, what would become the first aeroplane, by learning what didn’t work. Stalling the plane is less than ideal. The brothers learned why it was happening so they could avoid it, but they went a step further, learning how to stall on purpose.
It would be hard to say that the Wright Brothers were lucky to create an airplane. They earned that.
But who of the brothers was actually first? The plane was a one-seater, so that first flight would be a solo.
It turns out, the honor went to Orville.
How did he earn the honor? How did they decide?
Come on, you know how they decided.
They flipped a coin.
Wilbur won the toss. He stalled on takeoff.
Another, in a long line of failed attempts.
Orville got the next shot.
Maybe there was a little luck involved.
Lucky & Good
Hall of Fame pitcher, Lefty Gomez said, “I’d rather be lucky than good.”
Those are words I’ve heard and understood for a long, long time. But I think it’s important to understand, this is not a binary choice. True, there is a sliding scale between luck and skill, and it’s also true that, if we can pick one, luck is a damn fine choice.
Elon Musk, while walking into Mission Control before the first manned space launch from US soil in almost a decade, said, “I believe luck is the best superpower. If you can have any superpower, luck is the one you’d want.”
Luck. From the physics-loving engineer turned CEO billionaire.
But the better option is to ignore what Gomez and Musk say, and instead, do what they do.
Be lucky and good.
Manu Ginóbili is in the Hall of Fame. He had tremendous skill.
Getting drafted by the Spurs and playing most of his days with Tim Duncan? Well, that feels pretty lucky to me.
But why couldn’t he just miss that shot?
Even I could do that.
What he was attempting was something different. It was more difficult than making a basket. He was trying to miss, but miss in a very precise way, to control the rebound, and have that go to a particular player, so they could win the game. To do that, he needed it to hit the rim, and bounce in a specific direction, with a particular hang time.
When you think about it that way, and I have, making it is a breeze in comparison.
“That’s the way the ball bounces” is not just a clever phrase, it’s an admission that you can’t control everything. And those things you can’t control are where the luck is hiding.
Let’s just not pretend it’s not there.
Well, as you may have guessed I never did complete my PGA Professional training. I never got better than a bogey golfer. But I did learn a thing or two about myself, and about the skill required in that profession.
And that test, not just shooting low but making all the shots, is a frame I have not been able to unsee.
The difference between luck and skill is not always clear. It’s also not a choice.
It’s better to be lucky than good. Maybe. But I’m striving for lucky and good.
If you enjoyed this, share it with a friend.
Get the next one by email. New essays, plus email-only extras, downloads, and audio.
Enjoying the Flynnternet? You can support the writing.